Sheboygan takes its brats seriously and for good reason — it’s viewed by most as the birthplace of the American-style brat beloved by so many.
Several Hall of Fame bratwurst makers hail from the Sheboygan area and the town and citizens take their brats very, very seriously.
We’ve outlined all the steps below to cook up your own Sheboygan-style brats at home — i’s up to you to follow them EXACTLY or incur the wrath of a horde of angry Sheboyganites!
Sheboygan takes its brats seriously enough to have its own brat oath.
There’s not much difference in Sheboygan-area brats compared to other brat makers in Wisconsin, with many relying on salt, pepper, and nutmeg as spices, with varying amounts of mace, garlic, sage, and ginger also sometimes added.
So don’t despair if you can’t find Sheboygan brats to cook, as you’ll be in the general ballpark with anyÂ quality pork or beef/pork bratwurst that you have on hand.
Frying Your Sheboygan Brats
You never “grill” Sheboygan brats, you always “fry” them.
Don’t break out the deep fryer just yet, though — in Sheboyganese it means exactly the same thing when it comes to brats, so yes, you’ll be grilling them and that’s how we’ll refer to the process for the sake of simplicity.
While we recommend that you simmer your brats in beer first before grilling, that is definitely NOT the Sheboygan way.
Sheboygan brats are always grilled over charcoal and they go straight from the package to the grill.
Fire up your charcoal grill and wait until the coals have burned down to a grayish, white color.
Carefully place your brats on the grill with your fingers — never use a fork or you’ll puncture your brat casings and let all the juicy goodness out.
Grill your brats for about 20 minutes, and roll them over periodically with your fingers to ensure all sides are cooked and get a nice char.
They should stiffen up and be firm when they’re done; continue to grill if they feel soft or squishy to the touch.
Serving Sheboygan Brats
Inglehoffer stone ground mustard is the mustard of choice for many bratwurst purists.
Serve your brats up immediately when they’re done on the grill.
Sheboygan bratwurst is traditionally served up on a hard semmel roll, which is a round roll about the size of a hamburger bun that easily accommodates two brats at a time — a “double”.
Finding brat rolls can be hard in some areas so you may have to improvise with other hard rolls.
Just be sure to use a hard roll, as it has to stand up to all the juices that a perfect brat will produce. Never use soft hot dog buns to serve a brat on.
Yes, ketchup. Many brat lovers swear that ketchup has no place on a brat but in Sheboygan it’s considered perfectly normal to add ketchup to your brat.
You’ll also notice that we don’t mention sauerkraut or relish. That’s for a good reason, as both are considered verboden on a traditional Sheboygan brat.